Hunky Jesus Reel Voices Review
By Lottie Gale
By Lottie Gale
It’s Easter Sunday in Mission Dolores Park, San Francisco. The fierce spring sunshine beats down on a stage, a heavily sequinned crowd, and an oiled up ‘Jesus’ pole dancing on a cross. Loincloths not compulsory. Stilettos, encouraged.
Thanks to director Jennifer M. Kroot’s latest documentary HUNKY JESUS (2026), global audiences can embrace the eponymous festival that has set Californian Easter alight since 1999. Conceived (oh so immaculately) by the storied Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence, an exquisitely-named volunteer group of queer and trans nuns, the Hunky Jesus competition supports their mission to “promulgate universal joy and expiate stigmatic guilt”. Kroot interweaves footage of the 2023 edition, interviews with organisers, friends and dissenters of the festival, and archival material documenting almost 50 years of the Sisters’ radical activism. The result is a vibrant, raucous foregrounding of joyful resistance.
On the ground in 2023, Kroot and her team largely let the crowd speak – or cheer – for themselves, in their search for the year’s hunkiest Jesus and foxiest Mary. After all, this not-for-profit event led by a volunteer organisation reaps its reward in the wide community it champions. They show up for each other: year in, year out. Whether it’s the attention to detail in a glorious feather crown, or the long-time stage manager Jimmy wrangling contestants in fluffy bunny ears, HUNKY JESUS successfully captures the extraordinary effort behind staging such a high-energy event. Perhaps peppier cuts between more contestants during the competition sequences would enable their irreverent creativity to really dazzle in its abundance – from Mid-Life Crisis Jesus to Free Choice Mary, of course we want more where that came from.
For all the hilarity and celebration, HUNKY JESUS also knows how to take its subject seriously. Interviews with local figures of the Catholic Church give voice to concerns about blasphemy and over-sexualisation of their religion, while also drawing poignant parallels of felt connection to the Sisters and their work. When placed in conjunction with a concise timeline of the Order’s support and advocacy for San Francisco’s gay community during the early years of the AIDS pandemic, what emerges is a thoughtful probing of faith and belonging. Weighty topics are handled by reminding us that release is crucial for any community – for the Hunky Jesus audience (of both the competition and documentary), and beyond. Take it from one Foxy Mary contestant, donning a hat delicately embroidered with the statement “my body, my choice”. Discussing their outfit with one of Kroot’s team, this Mary takes pause to remove their large, reflective, heart-shaped glasses and say, somewhat wearily: “It’s been a rough year to have a uterus”. Amen.
The Sisters encourage diversity of expression because the challenges and crippling political agendas they face are universal, and exhausting. These moments of pure expressivity and understanding shared with the community are what make HUNKY JESUS a special, compassionate feature. Occasionally, Kroot employs a kaleidoscopic visual effect on the Sisters: repeated triangles twisting nun’s habits with angular eyebrows, extravagantly filling every inch of the screen. One central axis with countless refractions, reflections, interpretations… how fabulous it looks.